


Why do you make the imperfection of Christian obedience an argument against Christian obedience at all? Does the inability of fallen human beings to merit or earn salvation by good works, mean that they’re released from the responsibility to love God and keep His commandments? NO WAY! We’re not initially brought into right standing with God by the merit of any of our works, but neither does the grace of the Gospel of Christ authorize us, permit us, nor excuse us, to the point of continuing to knowingly live in willful, intentional, and blatant mortal sin that we can actually do something about.
The same Lord Jesus Christ who forgives sinners also calls them to Bible holiness. The same faith that receives the righteousness of Christ must work by love (Galatians 5:6). Don’t confuse your inability to earn or merit salvation because of your imperfection:–with the total absence of needing to obey God in your life! (Romans 15:18). Nor should you falsely assure a man into a false security of salvation, who stubbornly holds onto his beloved vices: that simply because he’s convinced Jesus is real, and says that he believes in God’s existence, that this somehow makes his final salvation from Hell totally certain, regardless of how he lives his life or doesn’t live his life for God (James 2:19). Preach free grace to the unconverted sinner! Yes sir! But preach the Bible grace that leads people to deny ungodliness and worldly lusts (Titus 2:11-14).
Because if you don’t do this, then you’re as guilty as sin, a total false teacher, and criminally insane enough to say that unchanged and unrepentant sinners–not born again of the Holy Spirit–will inhabit Heaven with the holy God that gave us life, men and women completely unchanged in their hearts–fornicators, idolaters, adulterers, girly men, homosexuals, thieves, greedy, alcoholics, mean people, swindlers, witches, fight pickers, people without self-control, antinomians, universalists, agnostics, atheists, evolutionists, jealous people, murderers, partiers, people who never share Christ with the lost, pimps, pornographers, human traffickers, and habitual liars–that all these people will definitely go to Heaven when they die…simply because they believe Jesus is real. NO! You’ve got to be joking. Your theology is laughably false. Such people will “have their part in the lake which burneth with fire and brimstone” (Revelation 21:8; rf. 1 Corinthians 6:9-10; Galatians 5:19-21).
—
ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY.
Taken together, the writings below argue that God’s grace does not abolish God’s moral law, excuse deliberate sin, or remove the believer’s responsibility to live in obedience to Jesus Christ. John Fletcher’s Checks to Antinomianism, John Wesley’s two Dialogues Between an Antinomian and His Friend, Daniel Steele’s A Substitute for Holiness, and Martin Luther’s Against the Antinomians all challenge the idea that justification by faith makes obedience, holiness, repentance, or the moral commandments unnecessary for the Christian life. They emphasize that salvation is not earned by good works, BUT genuine saving faith produces a changed lifestyle. The believer is called to resist sin, pursue holiness, obey God’s commandments, and continue in faith. Dr. Harald Lindstrom’s Wesley and Sanctification further explains Wesley’s understanding of sanctification, emphasizing the transforming work of the Holy Spirit and the believer’s growth in holiness. The central Wesleyan-holiness message is that we are saved by grace through faith, not by good works, BUT we are saved from the power of sin, and are NOT given permission to just continue living in it on purpose.
The remaining works apply these principles to the modern Lordship Salvation controversy. Mark Jones’ Antinomianism argues that Christ is not merely our Substitute for justification, BUT ALSO our example for sanctification, and that God’s moral law remains a guide for Christian living (that is, the third use of the law as taught by John Calvin). David Cloud’s “Repentance and Lordship Salvation” challenges any type of evangelism, that leaves out the call to repentance, or separates receiving Christ from acknowledging Him as your personal Lord. John MacArthur’s The Gospel According to Jesus and his “15-Year Retrospective” both argue that genuine saving faith always includes repentance, submission to Christ’s authority, and a transformed life; obedience is always the fruit of salvation, just not its initial purchase price. Robert Lescelius’ Lordship Salvation: Some Crucial Questions and Answers defends this teaching against common objections. Their collective warning is against any false assurance of salvation, that’s based on a superficial profession of faith, while deliberately continuing in unrepentant sin. Although these authors differ in their theological traditions, they share the conviction that grace and holiness cannot be separated, that real repentance from vice matters in salvation, and that genuine saving faith produces sincere but imperfect obedience to the commands of Jesus Christ, and is never to be separated from His atoning blood.
While the Calvinists would lean towards John MacArthur (Grace to You), David Cloud (Way of Life), some conservatives in the Southern Baptist Church (SBC), or the Presbyterian Church in America (PCA)–the Wesleyan-holiness advocates like myself would lean towards Church of God (Cleveland), Church of the Nazarene, the Wesleyan Church, the Bible Methodist Church, the Free Methodist Church, Church of God (Holiness), the Evangelical Methodist Church, the Christian & Missionary Alliance (A. W. Tozer people), Assemblies of God (David Wilkerson and Leonard Ravenhill people), the International Pentecostal Holiness Church (IPHC), and the Foursquare Church. On the Calvinist side, it would be the Master’s Seminary to train Calvinistic lordship preachers; on the holiness side, it would be God’s Bible School & College, Wesley Biblical Seminary, and the Pentecostal Theological Seminary that would have the strongest alignment against antinomian ideas.
John Fletcher, Checks to Antinomianism (Beacon Hill Press, 1948).
John Wesley, “A Dialogue Between an Antinomian and His Friend” (1745).
—. “A Second Dialogue Between an Antinomian and His Friend” (1745).
Daniel Steele, A Substitute for Holiness: Antinomianism Revived (Schmul, 1980).
Mark Jones, Antinomianism (P&R Publishing, 2013).
Martin Luther, “Against the Antinomians.” Luther’s Works, vol. 47 (Fortress Press, 1971).
David Cloud, “Repentance and Lordship Salvation” (Way of Life, 2010).
John MacArthur, The Gospel According to Jesus (Zondervan, 1994).
—. “A 15-Year Retrospective on the Lordship Controversy” (Grace to You, 2003).
Dr. Harold Lindstrom, Wesley and Sanctification (Zondervan, 1984).
Robert Lescelius, Lordship Salvation (Revival Literature, 1992).
